The 12 Best Eyeliner Pencils of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

We spent hours researching and testing the best eyeliner pencils for every makeup look —and our picks include gel pencils for tightlining, kohl for along the waterline as well as color and metallic options.

The 12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners, Tested in 2024 Drugstore eyeliner, Best drugstore eyeliner, Eyeliner products

Best Eyeliner Reviews - Top Eyeliners Tested and Reviewed

Best Drugstore Eyeliner of 2021

Kosas Super Creamy Revealer Concealer Review (& Best Dupes!). Thrive Eye Brightener Dupes

America's #1 longwear eyeliner is versatile, intense, and now, even more long-lasting. Our Revlon ColorStay Eyeliners have a new, improved formula that glides on easily and stays where it should for up to 24 hours. Draw precise lines with the sharp pencil tip, or blend and diffuse eye makeup with the built-in smudger for a smoldering, smoky look. It's one versatile pencil eyeliner that can create classic liner styles like cat eyes, as well as high-drama looks.

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil, Black 201 - 0.01 oz

The Best Eyeliner Pens and Pencils, According to Celebrity Makeup Artists

14 Best Eyeliners for Tight Lining That Ensure Ultimate Precision

January 2023 Brazil Photo Illustration Five Inc Logo, 56% OFF

12 Best Eyeliners 2022 - Top-Rated Black Eyeliner Reviews

Mixed Romantic Bouquet Chocolates, 57% OFF

Best liquid eyeliners in 2024